This is a guide for just the Nightmare pages if you’ve gotten everything on your standard playthrough. These pages are also included in the separate Episode guides if you want to see everything together.

Waking up to a Nightmare
NM 1 – On the tree that has fallen that you use to get over the fence. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]
NM 2 – On the path after getting off the log bridges. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]
NM 3 – Head around to the back of the gas station and the page is on the wall next to the bathroom door. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]

Elderwood National Park
NM 4 – In the middle of the road right before you get back to Barry. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]

On The Run
NM 05 – Right after the railroad bridge you’ll head up and see a chain link fence. Head up and right and the page is on a tree stump. [NIGHTMARE ONLY] (thanks to LoW SnakeZz)

Mirror Peak
NM 06 – To the left as you enter the ghost town on a wooden fence. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]
NM 07 – In the building on the left after the bridge. Go around to the far side. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]

The Anderson Farm
NM 08 – Continue back and the Page is on the door of a outhouse past the working windmill. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]

Bright Falls Light & Power
NM 09 – Down the street to the left when you see the bridge control building. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]
NM 10 – When Weaver sends you to do the floodgate hug the left wall all the way back to the building side. It’s on a rock. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]
NM 11 – On the downed tree right after MP 82 where the birds attack. [NIGHTMARE ONLY]

On the Road to Cauldron Lake
NM 12 – On a bench just to the right of the sign in the Majestic office. [NIGHTMARE ONLY] (Thanks to LoW SnakeZz)
NM 13 – On the top floor of the barn just past the monster truck. [NIGHTMARE ONLY] (Thanks to LoW SnakeZz)
NM 14 – On the top floor of the main Auto Salvage building. [NIGHTMARE ONLY] (Thanks to LoW SnakeZz)
NM 15 – On the back of the fence surrounding the generator in the area with the rotating lift. [NIGHTMARE ONLY] (Thanks to LoW SnakeZz)